ClearCount Medical Solutions

ClearCount Medical Solutions

Technology Comparison


RFID Bar-Code EAS (RF)
Overview
  • Sponge Counting and Detection System
  • Utilizes small, passive RFID tags embedded in surgical sponges
  • Tags contain tiny microchips and no battery
  • Tags do not transmit any digital information until they are within a predetermined range of the reader's antenna
  • Once scanned in, data from each sponge is validated and displayed on monitor
  • Sponges are automatically scanned out when discarded into plastic lined receptacle
  • Hand-held wand equipped with LEDs, and audible and visual indicators on the receptacle alert user of detected sponge(s) in case of patient scan
  • Sponge Counting and Documentation System
  • Utilizes sponges labeled with individual serial numbers embedded in a data matrix bar code
  • Bar codes are scanned by a reader to record codes during counts
  • Scans in multiple sponges at one time using a separate tag embedded on the band of wrapped sponges
  • Generates reports to display sponge counts/patient and staff information/staff notes and changes
  • Sponge Detection System
  • Utilizes surgical sponges and gauze tagged with an RF sensor
  • Non-Identification based tags
  • Uses disposable wand to detect tag frequency in the event of patient scan case
Pre Surgery
  • Enables manufacturers to verify the correct number of sponges in packaging.
  • Reduces the chance of miscounts.
  • Minimizes time spent on defective packs.
  • Requires line-of-sight to be scanned by reader.
  • Unable to validate the number of items inside a sealed package.
  • Does not transmit unique identifiers when scanned.
  • Readability breaks down when multiple tags are close together.
  • Not suitable for validating the number of items in a sealed package.
In Count
  • Enables the system to confirm that all tags in a pack of sponges are functional.
  • The system reads and records a unique identification number for each sponge.
  • Verifies the proper quantity of items in the pack.
  • All validation steps are performed within one second of presenting a pack of sponges to the device regardless of orientation.
  • Starting inventory is highly reliable.
  • The system meets and exceeds AORN guidelines.
  • Utilizes a master tag scan to speed up the in count process.
  • The master tag is printed on a band wrapped around a number of surgical sponges.
  • Relies on an assumed count as starting inventory since individual sponges are not scanned.
  • The functionality of each barcode is not checked prior to surgery.
  • Does not conform to AORN guidelines if sponges are not counted individually.
  • Provides no method for counting sponges into surgery.
  • Does not offer verification of tag functionality prior to surgery.
  • No data is transmitted from EAS tags and manual counting is required.
Out Count
  • The system counts any number of sponges discarded in receptacle regardless of orientation.
  • Provides a 1 to 1 reconciliation by matching unique ID numbers to counted in sponges.
  • Device performs an inventory of receptacle once per second, averaging in over 10,000 inventory counts per procedure.
  • Reduces chance of miscount.
  • No separation or orientation of sponges required.
  • Sponges are counted out of the procedure manually, one at a time.
  • The barcode must be wiped clean and oriented properly with the line-of-sight reader.
  • Multiple (redundant) reads are not part of the barcode process.
  • Results in a more labor intensive count than manual counting.
  • Provides no method for counting sponges out of a surgical procedure.
Scanning, Detection
  • Provides a two part patient scanning solution consisting of the SmartWandTM working in conjunction with a SmartTag™.
  • Feedback that the SmartWand is functional and reading through the patient provides optimal safety.
  • When items are detected, the quantity and description of items are displayed.
  • Faster than the current practice of X-Ray detection and there is no interpretation required.
  • Provides no method for scanning the patient in the event of a non-reconciliation.
  • Not capable of providing users with feedback of wand functionality or read range.
  • When items are detected, EAS technology is not capable of identifying the quantity or type.
  • Susceptible to false positives as well as degradation of performance, due to readability breaks-downs when multiple tags are close together.
Closing
  • The SmartSponge System software enforces 100% compliance by requiring that counts are reconciled before a case can be ended.
  • An Administrator-level override is required if a case must be ended with an unreconciled count.
  • Reduces risk of ending surgery with a retained sponge.
  • Enforces standardized sponge counting practices.
  • Provides no method for ensuring counts are reconciled before the case is ended.
  • Provides no method for ensuring counts are reconciled before the case is ended.
PDF Download - RFID as Most Complete Solution

Download Our Brochure
ClearCount Medical Solutions

Select a technology that gives you choices for configuring your O.R., now and in the future.
SmartSponge® System
AND/OR
SmartWand-DTX